Study after study is showing that short-term vacation rentals negatively impact neighborhoods. That's true even in parts of cities where STVR are not prevalent, as the San Diego affordable housing study on this page shows. STUDIESSAN DIEGO VAC. RENTAL DATAPENN STATE STUDYNYC-AIRBNB STUDYUNITE HERE SAN DIEGO STUDY
Big step taken
in STVR fight
Panel advances home-sharing proposal,
declines on whole-home rental plans
MARCH 24, 2017 - In a victory for opponents of short-term vacation rentals, San Diego's Smart Growth and Land Use Committee today agreed that only a proposal regulating home-sharing should go before the entire City Council with its recommendation. At the same time, the panel declined to push for any of three options brought by the Development Services Department (DSD) dealing with whole-home rentals.
The decision of the committee has the effect of separating home-sharing - where owners are present and rent out rooms - from whole-home rentals, where no owners are on site. And, because today's three draft proposals were considered by a three-person panel that included the two staunchest supporters of vacation rentals on the City Council, the decision may mean more restrictive action on whole-home rentals is possible when the issue goes before a more-balanced full City Council.
The full City Council will likely next take up the vacation rental issue in late August or early September, when DSD staff said it could come back with more details.
After hours of testimony today, Councilmember Chris Cate quickly made a motion to adopt Option 3 offered by the DSD. The plan was the most lenient of three options regarding whole-house rentals and closely mirrored a plan offered by Cate himself. Smart Growth Chair Scott Sherman seconded the Cate's proposal. However, the third member of the panel, Councilmember Georgette Gomez, said that while she could support the home-sharing part of the DSD Option 3 plan, she would not support the part of the plan dealing with whole-home rentals. So, the vote was 2-1. However, because only three members of the panel were present, a unanimous vote was needed for passage.
Gomez then made a motion to recommend the home-sharing part of Option 3, but not recommend any option for whole-home rentals. Cate seconded the motion. It passed 3-0.
"I feel there's a big difference between owner-occupied home-sharing and whole-home rentals where the owner is not around when issues potentially arise, especially at night and on weekends," said Gomez. "Particularly, I feel there is a difference between investor-owned whole-home rentals and those simply trying to make ends meet. It is primarily these properties that are not owner-occupied that seem to be contributing to negative impacts, whose effects are being felt throughout neighborhoods, primarily in single-family neighborhoods. For those reasons, I feel this issue should be addressed separately."
Gomez also said Councilmembers Barbara Bry (District 1) and Lorie Zapf (District 2) should have significant input on any vacation rental proposals because their districts are the most affected by the issue.
Quotes from the Smart Growth
hearing on vacation rentals
City Attorney: Short-term vacation rentals
not permitted under City's Municipal Code
San Diego City Attorney Mara Elliott has issued a memorandum of law advising the City Council and Mayor that short-term vacation rentals (STVR) are illegal in the city's residential zones.
"The City has a "permissive zoning ordinance." This means that any use that is not listed in the City's zoning ordinance is prohibited. Short-term vacation rentals are not specifically defined, expressly permitted, or listed in any of the zone use categories, including residential or commercial," Elliott said in her memo, issued on March 15.
You can read the entire two-page memo below.
The memo is a game-changer in a struggle begun by citizens in 2007 to regulate STVR. Save San Diego Neighborhoods and others have long argued that the San Diego Municipal Code prohibits owner-unoccupied vacation rentals in residential zones. The memo confirms that view is, and has been, correct.
Armed with this memo, as well as dozens of supporting legal opinions, Save San Diego Neighborhoods will be working to protect San Diego neighborhoods by stopping the sale of homes that may be converted to STVR hotels. Additionally, SSDN will be releasing information on steps that can be taken now against existing illegal STVR hotels in San Diego. Please check back to www.SaveSanDiegoNeighborhoods.org for updates.
The City Attorney memo comes at a time when the City's Smart Growth and Land Use Committee is scheduled to again take up the vacation rental issue on March 24. An ordinance offered by Council Members Barbara Bry and Lorie Zapf would address home-sharing (where the owners are present and rent out rooms).
In the wake of Elliott's memo, Bry issued the following statement:
"I was pleased to read the memo issued by City Attorney Mara Elliott confirming that short-term vacation rentals do not fall under any permissible use in the Municipal Code and are therefore prohibited in the City of San Diego. I look forward to working with my colleagues on the Council to determine the best way to allow property owners to participate in home sharing, while also enforcing existing City Code to protect residential communities from the proliferation of mini-hotels."
Please join us (form below) and check your email for details and updates in the coming days, as well as www.SaveSanDiegoNeighborhood.org.
Mini-hotels are illegal;
OK home-sharing, swapping
Join us, contact City Hall,
display a yard sign
Local planning groups,
councils all backing SSDN
Municipal Code is clear:
See the code, analysis
Please check back for updates in the coming days.
Join, support SSDN.
Neighborhoods are for neighbors.
Save San Diego Neighborhoods is a true "grassroots" group begun by concerned citizens after the Pacific Beach Planning Group passed recommendations to regulate short-term vacation rentals on March 3, 2015. We are a 401-C non-profit organization.
It is not legal for a company or individual to violate zoning laws and sell your right to a reasonable expectation of a peaceful residential environment, free from commercial impacts. That was one of the messages at the Smart Growth and Land Use Committee hearing. Realistically, the best outcome was advanced at the hearing with the panel separating home-sharing from whole-home rentals. See story below.